13 Best Fish Pans To Cook ANY Type Of Fish | Non Toxic & High Quality

pans to cook the perfect fish

08/13/2023

Konstantina Antoniadou

Now Trending:
Just For You:
Welcome To SKL!

My name is Danielle and I am a mother of two, wife, CEO, and lover of vintage treasures. I created SKL in 2020 to help our community in their need for well-researched and trust-worthy articles, listicles and guides to live a more sustainable and healthy life. So happy to have you here! (Click to learn more).

hello,

Sign Up For Our Free E-mail List That Folks Are Raving About!

Sign Me UP!

Our amazing newsletter is beloved by our SKL community and offers tips on living more sustainable, books to read, podcasts to listen to, inspiring conscious leaders to follow, discount codes from the best brands out there, and more!

SKL is reader supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn affiliate commission. Learn more here.

Looking for the best fish pants to help you cook any type of fish? 

Our list is chock full of healthy, non toxic, and high-quality fish pan options that promise to give that perfect crust to your favorite dishes. From nonstick grill pans and cast iron fish pans to wok pans, all options will easily elevate your cooking and last for generations. 

Don’t forget to check out our roundup of the safest non toxic cookware brands of 2024.

Best High-Quality and Non Toxic Fish Fry Pans in 2024.

nonstick grill pan

It’s no secret that we enjoy preparing delicious meals for ourselves and our loved ones. Our affinity for top-notch non toxic cookware and bakeware has led us to try almost every top-rated company under the sun. 

Heck, we even reviewed some seriously amazing non toxic air fryers.

However, today is all about choosing the best fish pans that can cook ANY type of fish. 

We need our fish fry pan to meet some specific quality criteria: 

  • Even heating: cooking the fish to perfection. 
  • Steady grip and easy maneuverability while cooking. 
  • Heat resistant to up to 500℉ and preferably compatible with all stovetops. 
  • Non-toxic and safe materials: no PFAS, PTFE, or PFOA, which can cause infertility, liver damage, and thyroid disease. And, of course, no Teflon – that’s notorious for releasing toxic fumes through off-gassing. 
  • Dishwasher friendly: saving us time and energy after a delicious meal.  

We gathered the 13 best fish pans that meet or exceed our quality demands. From cast iron fish pans to nonstick grill pans made of stainless steel, there’s something for everyone! Read on to find the 2024’s top-rated fish fry pan options.

What is the best pan to pan-fry fish in?

When it comes to pan-frying fish to perfection, the top recommendation is a good quality non-stick frying pan. Look for one specifically designed for cooking fish – you’ll want a size that comfortably fits the fish fillet or whole fish you plan to cook.

A non-stick frying pan is preferred because it helps prevent your delicate fish from sticking to the pan, making flipping and serving a breeze. Plus, it requires less oil to enjoy healthier and tastier fish dishes.

If you’re really into that crispy golden crust, you might also want to consider a cast iron fish pan. It’s perfect for giving your fish that beautiful sear and adding a nice depth of flavor.

What is the best type of non toxic cookware?

Ceramic cookware is made from natural clay and minerals, making it a safe and non-toxic choice for fish recipes. It is free from harmful chemicals like PFOA and PTFE, commonly found in traditional non-stick coatings. Ceramic cookware is also easy to clean and comes in various vibrant colors.

Cast iron is a classic and durable option used for generations to cook fish. Cast iron is great for heat retention and even cooking, but it requires proper seasoning and care to maintain its non-stick properties.

High-quality stainless steel cookware is another amazing and safe option. It is made from stainless steel, an alloy of iron, carbon, and other elements. Make sure to choose stainless steel cookware without any non-stick coatings, as some stainless steel pans may have non-stick layers that may not be entirely non-toxic.

Enameled cast iron combines the benefits of cast iron with a safe enamel coating. The enamel is free from harmful chemicals and provides a non-stick surface. Just make sure to choose high-quality enameled cookware without any questionable additives.

What kind of pan is best for deep frying fish?

The first option is a dedicated deep fryer designed explicitly for deep frying purposes. It has a built-in heating element, precise temperature control, and a large capacity for frying multiple pieces of fish at once. Many deep fryers also come with a frying basket, making it easy to safely lower and lift the fish from the hot oil.

However, a fish fry pan or a Dutch oven is the healthiest option. Look for fish pans with high sides and a thick, heavy base to ensure even heat distribution and stability. A pan with a capacity of at least 4 inches deep will allow you to comfortably submerge the fish in oil for crispy and even frying.

What pan is best for cooking salmon?

For cooking salmon, the best type of pan to use is a non toxic non-stick skillet or a cast iron fish pan. Safe Non-stick skillets are an excellent choice for cooking salmon because it prevents the delicate salmon fillet from sticking to the pan. It requires less oil or butter, making it a healthier option.  

Cast iron fish pans provide excellent heat retention and even heat distribution, allowing you to achieve a nice sear and crispy crust on the salmon. They can be reheated in the oven before cooking on the stovetop for a perfect crust. Just make sure your cast iron skillet is well-seasoned to prevent sticking.

No matter which type of skillet you choose, remember to preheat the pan before adding the salmon to get a beautiful sear. Use high-quality oil, butter, or your preferred cooking fat to enhance the flavor of the salmon.

This post is all about the best fish pans.


Best Non Toxic Fish Pan Picks To Fry Or Sear All Types of Fish:


1. Alva

best fish pan

Alva is a premium, Belgian-born cookware company with a rich history. It was founded in 1949 with a unique vision – repurposing discarded war materials and metals to create quality cookware. 

Starting with aluminum cookware, Alva has expanded its product catalog to include stainless steel, aluminum, cast iron, and carbon steel. 

In 2024, you can find many non toxic pans for cooking fish. From their energy nonstick fish pan and nori grill pan to wok pans and even nonstick grill pans! All are free of toxic PFOA and PFAS chemicals, of course.

Their commitment to sustainability extends to their manufacturing process. Their factory is powered by an impressive 30% solar power, contributing to cleaner energy usage and reducing their carbon footprint.

They also take care of their water usage with in-house water filtration. 

Price: $69+

Discount Code: Use SKL10 for 10% off!

Pan Specs: PFOA / PFAS free, Non Toxic | Frying pans come in cast aluminum, stainless steel, and carbon steel options

Location/Shipping: USA


Best Cast Aluminum Fish Pans from Alva:


2. Caraway

Pans for cooking fish

Caraway’s top-rated fish fry pan is a fantastic solution for healthy cooking without those pesky harmful chemicals. 

It boasts a non-toxic ceramic-coated interior that is completely free of PTFEs, which means you can cook your fish worry-free! 

This durable non-stick pan not only makes cooking a breeze but also makes cleaning up a joy—no more struggling with stuck-on food. 

It’s designed to work on various stovetops, including induction, gas, and electric—so no matter what kind of kitchen you have, this pan will fit right in. 

Oh, and you can crank up the heat to 550° without any issues, making it perfect for finishing off your fish dishes in the oven.

Price: $95

Discount: Save 10% via our link

Pan Specs: 550° heat, Non-Stick Ceramic, Aluminum Core, & Stainless Steel Handles, stovetop agnostic

Location/Shipping: USA


Best Non-Stick Fish Fry Pans from Caraway:


3. 360 Cookware

best fish pan

360 Cookware’s lineup includes some of the best fish fry pan options made of premium T-304 surgical-grade stainless steel. 

Whether you’re frying up a hearty breakfast for a hungry family or flipping omelets like a pro, this medium-sized fry pan has got you covered. The fry pan features ergonomic handles that make handling easy and comfortable. 

Plus, it’s oven-safe up to 500 degrees. Plus, the cladded metal and .110 gauge construction ensure durability and even heat distribution for consistent cooking results. 

And here’s the cherry on top – their pans are handcrafted in the U.S.A., guaranteeing authenticity and pride in every piece.

Price: From $99

Discount Code: SKL20 for 20% off

Pan Specs: Oven safe up to 500 degrees, Ergonomic handles, Stay cool long handle, Induction capable, Surgical grade stainless steel, USA Made

Location/Shipping: USA


4. Xtrema

best fish pan

In addition to their amazing non toxic cooking utensils, Xtrema offers a premium-quality oval fish pan made without metals– always 100% non-toxic. 

Its flared design makes transferring your delicious dishes from the pan to the plate a piece of cake. 

Plus, with its wide base, it’s perfect for cooking up a variety of dishes, whether it’s a small meal for yourself or a larger one for dinner parties or the whole family. 

After whipping up your culinary masterpieces, simply slip it into the dishwasher, and voila! It’ll be clean and ready for your next cooking adventure. 

To top it all off, Xtrema pieces are handcrafted by specialty Chinese ceramic artists.

Price: $70+

Pan Specs: All natural, 100% pure ceramic, Microwave, oven, BBQ, freezer and dishwasher safe, Stain and scratch proof, certified PFOA free, PTFE free, no extractable lead or cadmium

Location/Shipping: USA, international shipping available


5. Great Jones

Pans for cooking fish

Great Jones’s amazing fry family pans work beautifully as a non-toxic fish pan for all sorts of fish dishes!  

The Large Fry size is perfect if you often cook for a group or simply want to indulge in a large personal pancake. 

Plus, the fish fry pan works like a charm on all stovetops, including induction. So, no matter what kind of cooking surface you have, this pan is up for the challenge! 

The handle is welded, which means there are no screws, rivets, or seams to trap food or unwanted bacteria. Cleaning this oven-safe skillet becomes a breeze with no pesky crevices to deal with.

Price: $90+

Pan Specs: Ceramic nonstick on stainless steel, free of PTFE and PFOA chemicals, safe for all stove tops, 

Location/Shipping: USA, worldwide shipping


6. Made In Cookware

fish fry pan

Made In Cookware’s fish pans come in singles and in sets of two, boasting 8,526 glowing reviews; you know it’s a winner! 

The Carbon Steel material gives you superior heat control, allowing you to cook like a pro. And the best part is that it’s naturally non-stick so you can kiss those sticky messes goodbye! 

Plus, it’s oven safe up to a scorching 1200°F! 

So, whether you want to sear, bake, or broil, this pan can handle it all.

The set comes pre-seasoned with a delightful mixture of basso oil, coconut oil, and sunflower oil, saving you the trouble of the initial two seasonings. 

Price: From $145

Pan Specs: Made in Sweden, Oven Safe Up to 1200F, Carbon Steel, seasoned and unseasoned versions

Location/Shipping: USA


7. Our Place

best fish pan cast iron

Our Place’s best cast iron fish pan is basically an 8-in-1 bestselling cookware system that does it all.

We are obsessed with the sleek and ultra-modern design of this gorgeous cast iron pan!

With a 10.5-inch size, this fish fry pan is deep enough to roast a chicken and shallow enough to flip an egg with ease.

From braising to searing, steaming to straining, sautéing to frying, boiling to baking, serving to storing – the Cast Iron Always Pan 2.0 does it all!

Price: $155

Pan Specs: 8-In-1 toxin free enameled cast iron, 10-inch size, Heat resistance up to 500 degrees, 100 day trial, No seasoning required

Location/Shipping: USA


8. All-Clad

fish pan reviews

Next up is All-Clad’s best fish pan, designed with a large flat base and high round sides, making it perfect for browning and frying at high heat.

It’s a classic tri-ply design, which means it has an aluminum core bonded together with two layers of durable stainless steel all around.

This ensures maximum durability and super-fast, even heat distribution – no more hot spots ruining your cooking adventures!

Also, the high sides also allow for easy basting, so your dishes will be infused with incredible flavors.

And hey, it’s not just limited to stovetop use; you can safely use it in the oven or under the broiler up to a scorching 600°F!

Lastly, it’s proudly bonded, engineered, assembled in the USA, and backed by All-Clad’s Limited Lifetime Warranty. 

Price: $65

Pan Specs: Classic tri-ply construction, made in USA, oven/broiler-safe up to 600°F

Location/Shipping: USA


9. Staub

best fish pan

If you’re looking for premium pans for cooking fish, Staub’s cast iron fish pan has you covered.

You won’t need to go through the hassle of seasoning this cookware; it’s ready to rock right out of the box.

It has excellent conduction and roasting properties, allowing you to use less energy and fat in your cooking.

On top of that, the enamel coating is not only durable but also easy to clean, making your cooking experience a pleasure.

The oval shape adds a touch of elegance, making it a perfect oven-to-table dish.

Plus, the scratch-resistant surface ensures that this stackable cookware remains in top-notch condition for a long time, giving you plenty of delightful cooking sessions.

Price: $143.99

Pan Specs: Oven Safe up to 500F, Rough texture results in exceptional browning, Requires no seasoning, Dishwasher-safe, Made in France

Location/Shipping: USA


10. Milo Cookware

Cast iron fish pan

Next up is Milo’s raved-about cast iron fish pan, which is available in 6+ beautiful colors.

With its oven-safe design of up to 500℉ (260℃), it’s a versatile oven-safe skillet that can handle various cooking tasks, from stovetop to oven.

Plus, it’s compatible with all stovetops, including induction and ceramic, giving you the flexibility to use it on any cooking surface.

Baking? No problemo!

Combine it with our pre-cut parchment shapes for your non-stick baking needs, and you’re all set for easy and enjoyable baking sessions.

Also, you don’t need to worry about complex seasoning! This enameled cast iron skillet is user-friendly and requires no special care rituals.

Price: $105

Pan Specs: Safe to 500℉ (260℃), enameled cast iron (40% recycled cast iron), BSCI-certified factories

Location/Shipping: USA


11. Field Company

Cast iron fish pan

Another premium cast iron fish pan? You bet!

Field Company uses recycled iron sourced from US vendors to create their fish fry pan selection.

They’ve carefully optimized its weight and handle ergonomics to make it easy to maneuver around your stovetop, oven, and even grill.

Its heft is just right for high-heat searing, giving you that perfect crust on your favorite dishes.

Also, these cast iron fish pans are poured using green sand castings, just like the most celebrated vintage cast iron manufacturers, Griswold and Wagner.

Price: $145

Pan Specs: Recycled iron, ergonomic design, green sand castings, heirloom-quality

Location/Shipping: USA


12. Le Creuset

Cast iron oval dutch oven

Le Creuset’s best fish pan is perfect for searing, sautéing, stir-frying, and more.

Its interior surface features a black satin enamel finish that eliminates the need for traditional seasoning and maintenance of raw cast iron.

As you use it, the enamel develops a natural patina, making the skillet virtually nonstick and a breeze to clean.

Plus, thanks to its efficient heat retention, you can use lower heat settings both on the stovetop and in the oven, saving energy without compromising on results.

Lastly, when you bring this .oval fish pan to the table, your hot-covered dishes will keep the food warm, ready for second servings.

Price: 135 GBP

Pan Specs: Pan is oven-safe up to 500°F, tempered glass lid is oven-safe and broiler-safe up to 425°F, Enameled Cast-Iron

Location/Shipping: UK


13. Demeyere

Germany fish pan

Demeyere’s oval fish pan is made of high gloss polished 18/10 stainless steel, ensuring durability and a sleek appearance in your kitchen. 

It’s not just any stainless steel pan; it comes with a Duraslide® Ultra Coating that takes its nonstick abilities to a whole new level. 

Moreover, the fish fry pan boasts a 5-layer material that extends right up to the edge, guaranteeing excellent heat distribution across the entire surface. No more worrying about hot spots or uneven cooking! 

It is suitable for all types of stoves, including induction and oven-safe!

Price: €159

Pan Specs: stainless steel, high gloss polished – with Duraslide® Ultra Coating, suitable for all types of stoves, including induction

Location/Shipping: Germany


This post was about the best fish pans to cook any type of fish

And there you have it, folks! 13 high-quality and non toxic fish pans to cook any type of fish to perfection.

From cast iron grill pan for delicate fillets to stainless steel fish fry pans for that irresistible sear, there’s a perfect pan for every fish-loving chef.

If you enjoyed this article on the best fish pans, check out these other articles below!

chef fish pans
fish pans reviews

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.