11 Best Non-Toxic Baking Sheets & Bakeware in 2024, Tested & Reviewed

non toxic bakeware

12/08/2023

Danielle Alvarado

Now Trending:
Just For You:
Welcome To SKL!

My name is Danielle and I am a mother of two, wife, CEO, and lover of vintage treasures. I created SKL in 2020 to help our community in their need for well-researched and trust-worthy articles, listicles and guides to live a more sustainable and healthy life. So happy to have you here! (Click to learn more).

hello,

Sign Up For Our Free E-mail List That Folks Are Raving About!

Sign Me UP!

Our amazing newsletter is beloved by our SKL community and offers tips on living more sustainable, books to read, podcasts to listen to, inspiring conscious leaders to follow, discount codes from the best brands out there, and more!

SKL is reader supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn affiliate commission. Learn more here.

Looking for super safe baking sheets and bakeware to help you bake like a pro in 2024? 

We rounded up the best bakeware sets and investment-worthy pans from top-rated, non-toxic bakeware brands for you ahead.

Don’t forget to check out the 25 Best Non-Toxic Cookware Brands in 2024 for the safest pots & pans on the market!

Best non-toxic baking sheets and bakeware in 2024.

non toxic bakeware

Sure, when you hear Caraway, Great Jones, or Xtrema, you most likely think of ‘pots and pans.’ Yet, they’re more than just non-toxic cookware brands – they offer fantastic bakeware sets too!

Premium, display-worthy, and non-toxic, these brands have introduced PTFE, PFOA, lead, and cadmium-free bakeware for both seasoned bakers and beginners.

Whether you’re after non-stick pans for cakes or tackling stewing and sautéing (Le Creuset, we see you!), these non-toxic baking sheets have you covered.

Unfortunately, many regular baking sheets use Fluoropolymer (Teflon), which can release toxins at high temperatures.

So much so that over 97% of the U.S. population carries PFAS in their bodies, as reported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

Findings from a study conducted by the USGS reveal that nearly 50% of tap water in the United States, sourced from both public utilities and private wells, contains persistent chemicals.

However, PFAS has infiltrated our food system, too, thanks to nonstick cookware, utensils, and packaged food. 

But no worries! This year’s safest non-toxic bakeware brands stick to stainless steel, pure ceramic, glass, and cast iron. No nasties here–we promise!

We’ve narrowed down the options to the safest baking sheets and bakeware – scratch-resistant, free from harmful chemicals, and eco-friendly.

From curated 11-piece sets to stylish millennial pink pans, these top-rated brands will elevate your baking game and secure your pro-baker status.

What is non-toxic bakeware?

Non-toxic bakeware prioritizes safety, avoiding harmful substances like Teflon coatings. Traditional non-stick coatings, such as Teflon, can release toxic fumes when exposed to high temperatures, leading to health concerns.

Some bakeware may contain perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), which are associated with adverse health effects. 

Glass bakeware, ceramic-coated options, and stainless steel cookie sheets are among the best choices, free from toxic elements.

Also, silicone bakeware and non-stick baking sheets offer user-friendly alternatives without compromising health standards.  

Free Cleaning Ebook

What makes most baking sheets toxic?

Non-Stick Coating and Teflon  

Most nonstick pans turn potentially toxic due to the inclusion of non-stick coatings, often containing Teflon. When exposed to high temperatures, these coatings can emit harmful fumes, especially when used with acidic foods like tomato sauce.

Teflon coatings, commonly found in non-stick baking sheets, can pose health risks and contribute to environmental concerns.

Aluminum Cookware and Leaching 

Certain baking sheets, particularly those made from aluminum, may leach small amounts of aluminum into food over time.

Prolonged exposure raises concerns about potential health problems, emphasizing the importance of considering safer alternatives.

Porcelain Enamel, Lead, and Cadmium 

Bakeware with porcelain enamel coatings could contain toxic substances such as lead or cadmium, posing risks, particularly when used regularly.

Lead and cadmium are heavy metals that can be present in some bakeware, particularly those with porcelain enamel coatings. Long-term exposure to these toxic metals can lead to serious health problems, including neurological issues, kidney damage, and reproductive concerns.  

So, opting for 2024’s safest options that prioritize safety and quality, such as stainless steel, glass, or ceramic-coated bakeware, can contribute to a healthier cooking environment.

This post is about the best non-toxic baking sheets and bakeware brands.


The Safest Non-Toxic Bakeware Brands of 2024


1. Caraway

non toxic bakeware

When it comes to safe baking sheets and bakeware, not many options can rival Caraway’s non-toxic bakeware set. 

Featuring a ceramic-coated surface that won’t leach toxic materials like nasty PTFE, PFOA, lead, or cadmium into your clean and healthy ingredients, the 11-piece Caraway bakeware set has racked up rave reviews for its superior non-stick performance, even heat distribution, and easy cleaning. 

Caraway’s bakeware set comes with two baking sheets, muffin pans, one rectangular pan, one square pan, a loaf pan, AND two circle pans.

Plus, the set includes free organizers to keep your bakeware safely stored!

Personal Review: I have tested Caraway’s bakeware for over seven months now, and it is fantastic (and gorgeous). All of my desserts and entrees come out to perfection without any stuck-on issues. Just be sure only to use wooden or silicone utensils as metal will harm the coating.

Price: From $40+ for the “Square Pan”

Discount: Save an additional 10% with our link here! 

Material: Non-stick ceramic coating 

Location/Shipping: United States, ships worldwide 


Best Non-Toxic Bakeware from Caraway:


2. 360 Cookware

safest non-toxic baking sheets best non-toxic bakeware

Aside from the fantastic stainless steel cookware options, 360 Cookware‘s heirloom quality, non-toxic baking sheets and bakeware are also built to last a lifetime.

No, seriously, it comes with a lifetime warranty. 

From cookie sheets and jelly roll pans to pie pans and their stellar 5-piece bakeware set, everything is PTFE-free and handcrafted in the USA.

The eco-conscious materials? T-304 Surgical Grade Stainless Steel that’s oven safe for up to 500 Degrees.

Sure, there aren’t any cute colors to choose from, but this safe bakeware brand focuses solely on performance and eco-friendly materials, which is more than enough. 

Best Non-Toxic Stainless Steel Bakeware from 360 Cookware: 

Personal Review: If you love stainless steel as much as I do, you are going to fall head over heels with 360 cookware’s bakeware. It is the best quality stainless steel bakeware I have ever baked with and the lifetime warranty is the true icing on the cake.

Price: From $99+ for the “Round Brownie Pan” 

Discount Code: SKL20

Material: T-304 surgical grade stainless steel

Location/Shipping: United States, ships to Australia, Canada, Germany, Ireland, UK


3. Xtrema

non toxic bakeware

Xtrema is one of the most beloved non-toxic bakeware brands that use safe 100% natural ceramic to craft scratch-proof and high gloss bakeware. 

Amazingly enough, this durable oven-safe material can withstand up to 2500F! 

If you’re not a “ceramic coated” fan and want the real deal of 100% ceramic – this is the brand for you.

Also, a pretty affordable baker bundle includes their top-selling muffin pan, pie plate, and loaf dish for under $180! 

The company is FDA and California Prop 65 compliant and backs up its products with a 10-year warranty.

However, handmade, safe bakeware needs time to be perfected, so keep in mind that your order can take up to 20 days to arrive at your doorstep.

Best Non-Toxic 100% Pure Ceramic Bakeware from Xtrema: 

Personal Review: If you are new to 100% ceramic bakeware, you will instantly love it. Promise. It is shockingly lightweight and super easy to handle. It will never scratch like ceramic coating and it has a much longer lifespan. To top it all off, my abuela LOVES their entire line.

Price: From $82.99 for the “Muffin Pan” 

Discount Code: SKL15 for 15% off

Discount: Save 15% with the Baker’s Bundle Here!

Material: 100% pure ceramic

Location/Shipping: United States, ships worldwide 


4. Great Jones

non toxic bakeware

While we adore Great Jones’s engraved non-stick cookware, we also consider them one of the best non-toxic bakeware brands of 2024. 

The PFOA and PTFE-free, completely safe bakeware line is made from aluminized steel with nonstick ceramic coating. 

Think millennial taffy hot dishes, blueberry loaf pans, and beautifully colorful bakeware sets!

Of course, each set is also oven-safe up to 450 degrees. 

Additionally, you can recycle your old Great Jones baking sheets and cookware easily through their partnership with Hot Bread Kitchen. 

Best Non-Toxic Bakeware from Great Jones: 

Personal Review: When I received the Great Jones bakeware, the first thing that came out of my mouth was, “Omg, it’s just like grams!”. My Irish grandmother had a set just like theirs (circa 50+ years ago), and Great Jones was identical in that high-quality weight, feel, and usage. If you’re looking for a heavyweight, high quality, “just like they used to make it” bakeware – this is it.

Price: From $30+ for the “Patty Cake” 

Material: Aluminized steel with nonstick ceramic coating

Location/Shipping: United States 


5. Made In Cookware

non-toxic bakeware

Made In Cookware is not your basic safe bakeware brand.

They offer professional-quality, artisan-crafted, high-fired ceramic clay sets.

And get this! They are based on the 200-year-old porcelain recipe that boasts natural non-stick capabilities and high heat performance. 

Durable, thermal-shock resistant, and inherently stylish, the Made In bakeware sets come in 6 different colors and are made in France. 

Additionally, the brand offers high-fired ceramic clay sets if porcelain isn’t your thing.

Also, you can recycle your old cookware and bakeware through the Made In Recycling Program. 

Best Non-Toxic Porcelain Bakeware from Made In: 

Price: From $19+ for the “Sheet Pan”

Material: Porcelain 

Location/Shipping: United States, ships worldwide 


6. GreenPan

non toxic bakeware

Known as one of the safest non-toxic bakeware brands of 2024, GreenPan should definitely be on your radar. 

What sets these non-toxic baking sheets apart? A fantastic ceramic nonstick coating paired with a robust heavyweight gauge and a sleek one-piece design.  

The one-piece design, crafted from durable cast aluminum, not only guarantees exceptional heat transfer but also prevents any worries of warping.

And the best part? They are oven-safe up to an impressive 600˚F which gives you the versatility to explore various recipes.

And when it’s time to clean up, simply toss them in the dishwasher – easy and efficient.

From cake pans and muffin pans to safe baking sheets and splurge-worthy sets, the options are endless!

Best Non-Toxic Ceramic Nonstick Bakeware from GreenPan: 

Price: From $21.99+ for the “Round Cake Pan” 

Material: Ceramic nonstick 

Location/Shipping: United States 


7. Staub

non toxic bakeware

Crafted with the best traditional and modern techniques in northern France, Staub is free from PFOAs, PFAs, and all other harmful chemicals. 

Named as one of the best non-toxic bakeware brands Europe has to offer, each one of their options promises to retain heat and withstand up to 480°C, producing a delicious result for all of your favorite recipes.

The perfect stove to oven to table cookware for everyone who demands quality, safety, and aesthetics.

Best Non-Toxic Ceramic Bakeware from Staub: 

Price: From $39+ for the “Rectangular Baking Dish”

Material: Ceramic  

Location/Shipping: Worldwide Locations & Shipping


8. Le Creuset

the best baking sheets

Our affinity for Le Creuset’s chip-resistant, stain-resistant non-toxic tea kettles is well documented, but this time it’s all about their safest bakeware. 

Their aesthetically pleasing collection is made of enameled cast iron.

The coating is composed of “non-toxic metallic oxide particles suspended in a glass matrix,” so no harmful chemicals over here, folks — only even heating, stain resistance, and a 5-year warranty to back up their quality. 

Now, granted, they are not the most affordable non-toxic bakeware brand, but options like the heritage bakeware and square baker sets come with hundreds of raving reviews backing up their quality. So they are definitely worth it!

Best Non-Toxic Cast Iron Bakeware from Le Creuset: 

Price: From $42+ for the “Round Cake Pan”

Material: Enameled Cast Iron

Location/Shipping: Worldwide Locations & Shipping 


9. Lodge Cast Iron

non toxic bakeware

From cast iron baking sheet pans and casseroles to muffins, cornsticks, and pizza pans, Lodge has all our baking needs covered.

The premium quality, non-toxic baking sheets are seasoned with 100% vegetable oil and ready to use right out of the box. 

Plus, cast iron bakeware won’t dent, bend, or warp at high temperatures, which means you can pass this piece along with your family recipes. 

To top it all off, all pieces have been made in the USA since 1896 without PFOA or PTFE. 

Over the years, the company has also developed company-wide recycling programs, uncovered creative ways to reuse foundry sand, and switched to biodegradable packing materials!

Price: From $30+ for the “Iron Pie Pan”

Material: Cast Iron 

Location/Shipping: Worldwide 


10. Pyrex

non-toxic bakeware

Pyrex’s range of borosilicate glass pie and cake dishes can withstand extreme temperatures from -40°C to + 300°C.

They are also thermal shock resistant for up to 220°C. 

Currently, they offer 7 different options, ranging from flan and loaf dishes to baking sheets in many sizes.

Aside from offering the ideal material for non-toxic bakeware, glass also allows us to get sneak peeks during the super convenient baking process. 

And while Purex is generally a very affordable brand, you can also find their bakeware on the secondhand market pretty easily on sites like eBay or Facebook marketplace — just saying’.

Price: From $14.99+ for the “Baking Dish”

Material: Borosilicate Glass

Location/Shipping: Worldwide 


11. All-Clad

best bakeware brands

For non-toxic stainless steel bakeware, look no further than All-Clad

Crafted from 3 bonded layers of stainless steel and aluminum, this non-toxic baking sheet boasts maximum durability and superior heat distribution. 

Plus, with a generous flat surface and a convenient angled edge, effortlessly maneuvering in and out of the oven has never been easier.

Whether you’re baking, roasting, broiling, or serving, this sheet has you covered. 

Worried about utensil damage? The sheet is metal utensil-safe with oven/broiler-safe capabilities up to a sizzling 600°F!

Price: $129.99 

Material: Stainless Steel

Location/Shipping: United States


Non-Toxic Bakeware FAQs:


What is the safest bakeware for your health?

In 2024, there are many different types of cookware for virtually every taste.

Glass Bakeware

Considered one of the safest bakeware materials, glass does not leach harmful substances into food. Ideal for various baking needs, it’s a great option for health-conscious home cooks.

Stainless Steel Baking Sheets

Featuring stainless steel handles for ease of use and a premium stainless steel base, these sheets are the ideal choice for daily baking.

Stainless steel is a high-quality material, and one of the best options when it comes to durability and lowering your overall eco footprint. 

P.S. Choosing bakeware with stainless steel handles and smaller sizes can enhance ease of use and maneuverability, making them practical for daily use.

Additionally, using parchment paper instead of aluminum foil further minimizes exposure to potentially harmful substances.

Ceramic Cookware 

Ceramic cookware, including pots and bakeware, is a good option known for its safety and high quality. It’s a great choice for those looking to avoid potential health risks associated with other materials.

Silicone Bakeware

Known for its ease of use, silicone bakeware is a great choice for those looking for practical options. It is non-stick, making it suitable for a variety of baking needs.

How to choose the best non-toxic bakeware?

Materials

Opt for bakeware made from safe and non-toxic materials like stainless steel, ceramic, glass, or cast iron to avoid potential health risks associated with certain coatings or metals.

Coating

If you prefer non-stick options, choose bakeware with safe non-stick coatings. Look for brands that use PTFE-free and PFOA-free materials to ensure your health and safety.

Durability

Consider the thickness of the non-toxic bakeware material. Thicker materials, such as heavy-gauge aluminum or steel, often provide better durability and even heat distribution.

Versatility 

Look for bakeware sets that offer versatile pieces, such as baking sheets, cake pans, and muffin tins, to cover a range of baking needs.

Heat Resistance 

Check the bakeware’s oven-safe temperature ratings to ensure they can withstand the temperatures required for your baking recipes.

Ease of Cleaning

Consider bakeware that is dishwasher-safe for easy and convenient cleaning. This is especially important for items with intricate designs or hard-to-reach corners.

Budget – Set vs. Individual Pieces

Decide whether you prefer purchasing a bakeware set or individual pieces. Sets are often more cost-effective but may include items you don’t need.

Material Compatibility

Consider the type of recipes you frequently use and choose bakeware that complements those recipes. Different materials may be better suited for specific types of baked goods.

How do I clean and maintain my bakeware?

First, always refer to the specific care instructions provided by the manufacturer for your bakeware.

Hand wash with mild dish soap, warm water, and a soft sponge or cloth. Avoid using abrasive cleaners or metal utensils that can scratch the non-stick surface.

For stubborn stains, use a mixture of baking soda and water as a gentle abrasive. Dry promptly after washing to prevent water spots. Don’t forget to check for any damage, such as warping, before use.

Also, unless specified otherwise, avoid extreme temperatures that can damage certain bakeware materials.

How do I remove stuck-on food from bakeware? 

First, allow the bakeware to cool completely before attempting to remove stuck-on food. Then, fill the bakeware with warm, soapy water and let it soak for at least 15-30 minutes.

This helps to loosen the stuck-on food particles. After soaking, use a soft sponge or cloth to gently scrub the stuck-on food. Avoid using abrasive pads or metal scrubbers, as they can scratch the surface of the bakeware, especially non-stick coatings.

For tougher stains, create a paste by mixing baking soda with water. Apply the paste to the stuck-on food areas and let it sit for about 15 minutes. Then, scrub with a soft sponge or cloth.

For certain types of bakeware, such as cast iron, you can sprinkle salt on the stuck-on food and then rub it with half a lemon. The acidity of the lemon helps break down the residue.

Are aluminum baking sheets oven-safe?

Yes, aluminum baking sheets are generally oven-safe. However, it’s essential to be cautious with acidic or salty foods, as prolonged exposure may cause aluminum to leach into the food. To minimize this risk, consider using parchment paper or silicone mats on the aluminum sheet.

Is aluminized steel baking sheets safe?

Aluminized steel baking sheets are considered safe for most baking purposes. The steel core provides durability, and the aluminum coating offers even heat distribution. As with aluminum sheets, it’s advisable to avoid exposing them to highly acidic or salty foods for extended periods.

Are ceramic baking sheets good?

Ceramic baking sheets are generally considered good for various baking applications. They provide even heat distribution, are resistant to scratches, and often have a non-stick surface. Just ensure that the ceramic coating is free from lead or other harmful substances by checking product labels.

Is aluminum foil safe for baking?

When exposed to highly acidic or salty foods, aluminum can leach into the food being prepared. Prolonged exposure to acidic ingredients may lead to higher aluminum levels in the finished dish. High levels of aluminum intake have been associated with health concerns, including potential links to neurological issues.

However, the evidence on the health impact of aluminum exposure through food is still a subject of ongoing research. So, it would be best to opt for a great alternative like parchment paper or silicone baking mats to line baking sheets.

Do silicone baking sheets have PFAS?

Generally, high-quality silicone baking sheets do not contain PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances). However, it’s essential to check the specific product information or contact the manufacturer for confirmation, as the composition can vary between brands.  

Does silicone release toxins when heated?

Silicone is generally considered safe for baking as it does not release toxins when heated. It has a high heat resistance and is stable at typical baking temperatures.

However, it’s crucial to use silicone bakeware within its recommended temperature range and avoid exposing it to extreme heat.

Can I use metal utensils with non-stick bakeware?

It’s generally not recommended to use metal utensils with non-stick bakeware. Using metal utensils can compromise the integrity of the non-stick surface, leading to scratches and abrasions.

These scratches can, in turn, reduce the effectiveness of the non-stick properties and may expose the underlying material.

To maintain the longevity and performance of your non-stick bakeware, it’s advisable to use utensils made of materials that are softer than the coating, such as silicone, or wooden utensils.


This post was about the best non-toxic baking sheets and bakeware brands.

Did you know that baking can increase feel-good endorphins? Yes! That’s another excuse to opt for safe bakeware and perfect your cookie-making skills with the help of the best nontoxic bakeware brands 2024 has to offer.

If you enjoyed this article on Non-Toxic Bakeware, check out these other articles below!

non toxic bakeware