12 Days of Christmas Giveaway!

Click To Enter!

We are giving away over $8000 in Non-Toxic Cookware, Organic Skincare, Susty Fashion, & More!

9 Safest Non-Toxic Baking Sheets & Bakeware in 2024, Tested & Reviewed

teflon free bakeware


Sustainably Kind Living

25 Best Non-Toxic Cookware Brands, Tested & Reviewed!
101 Best Secondhand Gifts To Spread Thrifted Joy!
101 Best Sustainable Black Friday Sales of 2023!
Now Trending:
Just For You:
Welcome To SKL!

My name is Danielle and I am a mother of two, wife, CEO, and lover of vintage treasures. I created SKL in 2020 to help our community in their need for well-researched and trust-worthy articles, listicles and guides to live a more sustainable and healthy life. So happy to have you here! (Click to learn more).


Sign Up For Our Free E-mail List That Folks Are Raving About!

Sign Me UP!

Our amazing newsletter is beloved by our SKL community and offers tips on living more sustainable, books to read, podcasts to listen to, inspiring conscious leaders to follow, discount codes from the best brands out there, and more!

SKL is reader supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn affiliate commission. Learn more here.

Looking for scratch-resistant, chemical-free, safe baking sheets, and bakeware to help you bake like a pro?

We rounded up the best bakeware sets and investment-worthy pans from top-rated, non-toxic bakeware brands for you ahead.

Don’t forget to check out the 25 Best Non-Toxic Cookware Brands in 2024, Tested & Reviewed for the safest pots & pans on the market!

Best non-toxic baking sheets and bakeware in 2024.

best non toxic bakeware

Granted, when someone mentions Caraway, Great Jones, or Xtrema, we instantly think of “pots and pans.” But buckle your seatbelts, folks, because they are not only amazing cookware brands, but they also have some knockout bakeware sets you need to know about!

The equal parts premium quality, display-worthy, and non-toxic cookware brands have already debuted their high-performing, PTFE, PFOA, lead, and cadmium-free bakeware sets and singles for accomplished bakers and newbies alike. Some essential pans will help you bake your best-ever cakes, muffins, and cookies, while others can tackle stewing and sautéing as well — we’re looking at you, Le Creuset!

We whittled down the options to the safest baking sheet & bakeware that are scratch-resistant, free from all harmful chemicals, and eco-friendly. 

Free Non-Toxic Cleaning Recipe E-book!

Free Cleaning Ebook

Sadly, in most cases, regular baking sheets and ovenware are coated with Fluoropolymer — Teflon, aka polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). In high temperatures, this material can break down and release toxic fumes as well as leach toxic chemicals into your delicious baked goods. 

That’s why the safest non toxic bakeware brands solely use stainless steel, pure ceramic, cast iron, and gas that emits no toxins and does not react with ingredients!

From expertly curated bakeware sets of 11 pieces to aesthetically pleasing millennial pink pans and every type of safe bakeware you can think of, the top-rated brands below will help you claim your pro-baker status.

What is non-toxic bakeware?

If you want to opt for the safest bakeware for your health, look no further than stainless steel, cast iron, ceramic, and borosilicate glass. These materials can withstand very high temperatures and won’t leach any toxic chemicals into the food.

Bonus? They are friendly to the environment as well — which makes them a great alternative to toxic nonstick bakeware.

What makes most baking sheets toxic?

As we mentioned, Teflon, laced with something called perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), is one of the biggest offenders when it comes to toxic bakeware. This toxic chemical, mostly found in cheaper nonstick options, breaks down into our food in just a few minutes when overheating. The International Agency for Research on Cancer has classified PFOA as possibly carcinogenic to humans. 

This post is about the best non toxic baking sheets and bakeware brands.

The Safest Non Toxic Bakeware Brands of 2024

1. Caraway Bakeware

safest non toxic cookware brands

When it comes to safe baking sheets and bakeware, not many options can rival Caraway’s newly launched non-toxic bakeware set. 

Featuring a ceramic-coated surface that won’t leach toxic materials like nasty PTFE, PFOA, lead, or cadmium into your clean and healthy ingredients, the 11-piece set has racked up rave reviews for its superior non-stick performance, even heat distribution, and easy cleaning. 

The set comes with two baking sheets, muffin pans, one rectangular pan, one square pan, a loaf pan, AND two circle pans.

Plus, the set includes free organizers to keep your bakeware safely stored!

Price for Set: $545 (On Sale For $395)

Discount: Save an additional 10% with our link here! 

Material: Non-Stick Ceramic Coating 

Location/Shipping: USA, ships worldwide

The Best Non Toxic Bakeware:

2. Xtrema’s Ceramic Bakeware

non-toxic baking sheets

Xtrema is one of the most beloved non-toxic bakeware brands that use safe 100% natural ceramic to craft scratch-proof and high gloss bakeware. Amazingly enough, this durable oven-safe material can withstand up to 2500F! 

If you’re not a fan of “ceramic coated” and want the real deal of 100% ceramic – then this is the brand for you.

Also, a pretty affordable baker bundle includes their top-selling Muffin Pan, Pie Plate, and Loaf Dish for under $180! 

The company is FDA and California Prop 65 compliant and backs up its products with a 10-year warranty.

However, handmade, safe bakeware needs time to be perfected, so keep in mind that your order can take up to 20 days to arrive at your doorstep.

Price: Starts at $33.99

Discount: Save 15% with the Baker’s Bundle Here

Material: 100% pure ceramic

Location/Shipping: USA, ships worldwide

100% Pure Ceramic Bakeware:

3. Great Jones

best non-toxic bakeware

While we absolutely adore Great Jone’s engravable non-toxic cookware, we also consider them as one of the best non-toxic bakeware brands of 2024. The PFOA and PTFE-free, completely safe bakeware line are made from aluminized steel with nonstick ceramic coating. 

Think millennial pink hot dishes, blueberry loaf pans, and beautifully colorful bakeware sets! Of course, each set is also oven-safe up to 450 degrees. 

Additionally, you can recycle your old Great Jones baking sheets and cookware easily through their partnership with Hot Bread Kitchen. 

Price: Starts At $28

Material: Aluminized Steel With Nonstick Ceramic Coating

Location/Shipping: USA

Best Non Toxic Bakeware from Great Jones:

4. 360 Cookware Bakeware

safest non-toxic baking sheets best non-toxic bakeware

Aside from the fantastic stainless steel cookware options, 360 Cookware‘s heirloom quality Non-toxic baking sheets and bakeware are also built to last a lifetime — no, seriously, it comes with a lifetime warranty. 

From cookie sheets and jelly roll pans to pie pans and their stellar 5-piece bakeware set, everything is PTFE-free and handcrafted in the USA. The eco-conscious materials? 

T-304 Surgical Grade Stainless Steel that’s oven safe for up to 500 Degrees. Sure, there aren’t any cute colors to choose from, but this safe bakeware brand focuses solely on performance and eco-friendly materials, which is more than enough. 

Price: From $99+

Discount Code: SKL20

Material: T-304 Surgical Grade Stainless Steel

Location/Shipping: USA, ships to Australia, Canada, Germany, Ireland, UK

Best Stainless Steel Bakeware:

5. Le Creuset Bakeware

the best baking sheets

Our affinity for Le Creuset’s chip-resistant, stain-resistant non toxic tea kettles is well documented, but this time it’s all about their safest bakeware. 

Their aesthetically pleasing collection is made of enameled cast iron. The coating is composed of “non-toxic metallic oxide particles suspended in a glass matrix,” so no harmful chemicals over here, folks — only even heating, stain resistance, and a 5-year warranty to back up their quality. 

Now, granted, they are not the most affordable non-toxic bakeware brand, but options like the Heritage Covered Baker and Square Bakers sets come with hundreds of raving reviews backing up their quality — so they are definitely worth it!

Price: From $54+

Material: Enameled Cast Iron

Location/Shipping: UK, Worldwide Shipping Available

Non Toxic Cast Iron Bakeware:

6. Made In Ceramic Bakeware

non-toxic bakeware

Made In Cookware is not your basic safe bakeware brand. They offer professional-quality, artisan-crafted high-fired ceramic clay sets based on the 200-year-old Porcelain recipe that boasts natural non-stick capabilities and high heat performance. 

Durable, thermal-shock resistant, and inherently stylish, the Made In Bakeware Sets come in 6 different colors and are made in France. 

Additionally, the brand offers high-fired ceramic clay sets too, if porcelain isn’t your thing. Also, you can recycle your old cookware and bakeware through Made In Recycling Program. 

Price: From $25+

Material: Ceramic Clay

Location/Shipping: USA, ships worldwide

Non Toxic Ceramic Clay Bakeware:

7. Staub Cast Iron Bakeware

non-toxic baking sheets

Crafted with the best of traditional and modern techniques in the north of France, Staub Cocotte is Free from PFOAs, PFAs, and all other harmful chemicals. 

Named as one of the best non-toxic bakeware brands Europe has to offer, each one of their options promises to retain heat and withstand up to 480C, producing a delicious result for all of your favorite recipes.

The perfect stove to oven to table cookware for everyone who demands quality, safety, and aesthetics.

Price: From $25+

Material: Ceramic  

Location/Shipping: USA

Best Enameled Cast Iron Bakeware:

8. Pyrex Glass Bakeware

non-toxic bakeware

Pyrex’s bake and enjoy range of borosilicate glass pie and cake dishes can withstand extreme temperatures from -40 ° C to + 300 ° C while also being thermal shock resistant for up to 220 °. 

Currently, they offer 7 different options ranging from flan and loaf dishes to baking sheets in many sizes.

Aside from offering the ideal material for non toxic bakeware, glass also allows us to get sneak peeks during the baking process which is super convenient. 

And while Purex is generally a very affordable brand, you can also find their bakeware on the secondhand market pretty easily on sites like eBay or Facebook marketplace — just saying’.

Price: From $25+

Material: Borosilicate Glass

Location/Shipping: USA, ships internationally

9. All Clad Stainless Steel Bakeware

best bakeware brands

All Clad is one of our favorite non toxic bakeware brands for steel baking sheets that will last you years and years. 

Oven safe up to 500°F, All Clad’s sheets are equipped with an angled edge to ensure a safe grip.

Also, each and every piece is bonded, engineered, & assembled in the USA while also carrying a lifetime warranty!

As many reviewers mentioned, “It is worth the investment as you will never need to buy another again if you take care of them.”

It’s no wonder why they’ve been around since 1971!

Price: From $39.99+

Material: Stainless Steel

Location/Shipping: USA, ships internationally

The safest non toxic baking sheets & bakeware in 2024.

Did you know that baking can increase feel-good endorphins? Yes! That’s another excuse to opt for safe bakeware and perfect your cookie-making skills with the help of the best non toxic bakeware brands 2024 has to offer.

If you enjoyed this article on non toxic bakeware, check out these other articles below!

non toxic bakeware

Caraway cookware sets, Organic Skincare, Ethical Jewelry, Sutainable Fashion, Non-Toxic Bedding, Stunning Home Decor, and more!

As a HUGE thank you to our amazing SKL community, we are giving away over $8000 USD in amazing Non-Toxic & Sustainable prizes!

Sign Up To Enter!

*Begins December 1st!

Are you ready for the SKL 12 Days of Christmas Giveaway!?

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Steal My Non-Toxic Cleaning Recipes!

Believe us, it's the BEST.... and it's free. Does it really get any better than that?! Sign up for our newsletter and get this ebook packed with over 50 DIY non-toxic cleaning recipes sent directly to your email.


50+ DIY Cleaning Recipes For The Home


Ready To Become A Sustainable Fashion Pro?!

Curious about jumping into the sustainable fashion world but not sure where to start or who to trust? 

This is the ULTIMATE guide with endless resources to help you become an absolute pro at buying less, buying better, and inspiring others to do the same. 

Get Your Free ebook!