The 101 Best Secondhand & Thrifted Christmas Gift Ideas in 2023

best secondhand gift ideas

10/22/2023

Konstantina Antoniadou

Now Trending:
Just For You:
Welcome To SKL!

My name is Danielle and I am a mother of two, wife, CEO, and lover of vintage treasures. I created SKL in 2020 to help our community in their need for well-researched and trust-worthy articles, listicles and guides to live a more sustainable and healthy life. So happy to have you here! (Click to learn more).

hello,

Sign Up For Our Free E-mail List That Folks Are Raving About!

Sign Me UP!

Our amazing newsletter is beloved by our SKL community and offers tips on living more sustainable, books to read, podcasts to listen to, inspiring conscious leaders to follow, discount codes from the best brands out there, and more!

SKL is reader supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn affiliate commission. Learn more here.

Looking for the absolute best second hand gift ideas in 2023?  Our epic thrifted gift ideas will knock your socks off! 

We’ll help you snag one-of-a-kind, quality items at a fraction of the price. Sound good? Here’s our thrift store white elephant gift ideas and more for kids and adults.

P.S. Don’t forget to check out the 25+ Best Sustainable DIY Gifts For An Eco-Friendly Holiday Season.

The Best Second Hand Gifts for Christmas & Holidays in 2023!


Download The Full Secondhand Gift Giving Guide:

secondhand gifts for christmas

‘Tis the season of twinkling lights, gingerbread delights, crackling fires, and steaming mugs of warmth. 

Yet, amid the festive cheer, there’s another guest that often overstays its welcome – waste. Lots and lots of it! 

Now, don’t get us wrong, we love the magic of the holiday as much as the next person. But let’s face it, it’s also the season of excess, with unwanted gifts, plastic ornaments, and wrapping paper that could probably cover the North Pole and enough plastic packaging to build a Santa’s workshop.

One thing’s for sure during the holiday season – the gifts are flowing. And while giving is fabulous, there’s a fine line between thoughtful giving and overconsumption. 

Unlike the thoughtful secondhand gift ideas, all those brand-new gifts come at a price – the planet’s resources. 

Extra production means more raw materials extracted, more energy used, and more emissions pumped into the atmosphere. 

So next time you’re tempted to click “add to cart” on a brand-new item, consider hitting up your local thrift store or checking out online secondhand marketplaces for the best thrift store gift ideas. You’ll save money, score the unique second hand gifts, and “wow” your eco-conscious friend in the process. 

Happy secondhand shopping, folks! 

Why choose second hand gifts for the holidays?

Our beautiful planet could use a little extra love during the holidays. Shopping secondhand reduces the demand for new manufacturing, which in turn conserves precious resources, cuts down on energy consumption, and minimizes greenhouse gas emissions. 

Plus, when you shop secondhand, you’ll surely discover that one-of-a-kind vintage piece or a pre-loved gem tucked away in a thrift store. 

Seriously, who loves generic, unthoughtful gifts anyway? 

Our favorite thrifted gift ideas carry a sense of nostalgia and charm. Whether it’s a vintage record player, a classic board game, or a well-loved book, these gifts bring back memories and create new ones. You’re not just grabbing something off a shelf; you’re carefully selecting a gift that resonates with the recipient.

Also, who doesn’t love saving some holiday cash? Second hand gift ideas are often budget-friendly, letting you give thoughtful presents without breaking the bank. It’s a win-win for your wallet and your loved ones.

Let’s not forget that many secondhand shops and markets are locally owned or run by small businesses. When you shop secondhand, you’re supporting these enterprises and contributing to your community.

Is it okay to give thrifted gifts?

YES! Thrifted gifts are perfectly ok. They can be one-of-a-kind treasures that show you’ve put thought into your selection. What’s more, by reusing pre-loved items, you reduce the demand for new production, which conserves resources and reduces waste.

You can find quality items at a fraction of the price, allowing you to give meaningful gifts without breaking the bank. Plus, thrifted gifts typically come with minimal packaging, which reduces the amount of wrapping and packaging waste associated with holiday gift-giving.

How to gift second hand items?

First and foremost, consider the tastes and interests of the person you’re giving the gift to. What are their hobbies, favorite colors, or unique preferences? This will help you choose a secondhand item that resonates with them.

Ensure that the secondhand gift is in good condition. Look for items that have been well-maintained and show minimal signs of wear. A little refurbishing or cleaning might be necessary to make it look its best.

Always add a personal touch by pairing the secondhand item with something special. This could be a handwritten note, a homemade card, or a small accessory that complements the gift.

When presenting the gift, be open and transparent about its origin. Let the recipient know that you chose a secondhand item intentionally as part of your commitment to sustainability.

Packaging matters, too! Wrap the gift beautifully to make it feel as special as a brand-new item. Consider eco-friendly or reusable wrapping options, such as fabric or recycled paper. Here are our top Zero Waste Gift Wrapping Ideas for inspiration.

Remember, the thought and care you put into selecting and presenting a secondhand gift can make it just as special, if not more so, than a brand-new item!

This post is about the best thrifted gift ideas for Christmas.


101 Best Second Hand Gift Ideas in 2023!


1. Favorite childhood book

best sustainable presents

Remember the days when you’d dive headfirst into the magical worlds of Roald Dahl or J.K. Rowling, carried away by the adventures of beloved characters? 

Well, that’s the magic of books, and gifting someone their favorite childhood book is like handing them a portal to their fondest memories. 

You’re not contributing to more paper production, plus you might discover a beautifully preserved vintage edition that’ll charm the recipient even more. Double win!


2. Vintage American girl dolls

second hand gift ideas

When it comes to nostalgic-inducing thrifted gift ideas, American Girl dolls are are the top of our list. 

Each doll comes with a unique backstory, representing different time periods and cultures. They encourage creativity and empathy, making them a great educational tool. 

Whether it’s Samantha from the Victorian era or Addy from the Civil War, each doll has an oh-so-familiar vintage charm that adds character to the gift.


3. Favorite childhood toy

vintage gift ideas

We all had that one toy that used to be a part of every single one of our adventures and make-believe games. 

Talking about a real thrift store white elephant gift here! It’s time to reunite them with an old friend. 

Whether it’s a beloved stuffed animal, a vintage action figure, or a well-worn doll, gifting someone their favorite childhood toy is always a stellar idea.


4. Second hand wooden toys for the kids

best second hand gift ideas

Moving on to one of the best second hand gift ideas for little ones! You know darn well how much we love Wooden Baby Toys over here! 

They are an absolute gem. Not only are they eco-friendly, but they also offer a timeless charm and durability that plastic toys often can’t match. 

Plus, wooden toys are built to last. They can withstand rough play and still look great, making them a smart investment. 

Seriously, no matter if it’s building blocks, puzzles, or toy cars, these classics provide hours of entertainment.


5. Old wooden train sets 

absolute best second-hand gift ideas

All aboard the nostalgia train with yet another amazing thrift store gift idea! Old wooden train sets are a timeless favorite among kids. 

And when they come with a bit of wear and tear, they become even more appealing. 

Why? Because kids absolutely love to fix things up and put their creative stamp on their toys. They’re tactile, customizable, and encourage open-ended play. 

Plus, choosing secondhand is eco-conscious, reducing the demand for new toys *wink*.


6. Old Comic books

absolute best second-hand gift ideas

Bam! Pow! Zap! Is there anything more thrilling than diving into the colorful, action-packed pages of a vintage comic book? 

Comic book characters like Tintin, Mickey, Superman, Batman, Spider-Man, and Wonder Woman have captured the hearts of generations —it’s a gift that packs a punch!  


Download The Full 101 Secondhand Gift List!

secondhand gifts for christmas

7. Preloved electronics

second hand gift ideas

Ready for a tech-savvy twist on gift-giving? If you’re thinking of surprising someone with a new phone, a laptop, or a tablet, consider going the eco-friendly route by choosing a pre-loved, refurbished model instead. 

Not only does this choice reduce electronic waste, but it can also save you some serious cash. Refurbished electronics are often as good as new. 

They’ve undergone rigorous testing and come with warranties, so there’s no need to worry about quality. 

Marketplaces like Gizmogo have a slew of second hand gift ideas on their virtual shelves.


8. Vintage Jewelry

second hand gifts for holidays

Seriously, is there anything more amazing than the glimmer of vintage jewelry? 

They are not only the most Sustainable & Ethical Jewelry pieces you’ll ever find, but also hold a unique allure that modern pieces simply can’t replicate. 

Because when we’re choosing pre-loved pieces, we’re reducing the demand for new mining and manufacturing, making it a more responsible choice for the planet. A timeless gift for a timeless soul!


9. Vintage designer jackets

vintage gift ideas

You know that one friend who’s always on the hunt for premium-quality wardrobe staples? 

Vintage designer jackets are the best second hand gift ideas for a good reason! 

They are crafted with precision and top-notch materials, ensuring they withstand the test of time. They offer both warmth and style, making them versatile additions to any wardrobe. 

And let’s not forget that, by giving a pre-loved designer piece a new home, you’re contributing to sustainable fashion and reducing the demand for new, resource-intensive garments. Places like Vestriare Collective, Etsy, and Threadup.


10. Vintage tees

epic thrifted gift ideas

Vintage tees are all the rage, and for good reason. 

Here’s why they’re the perfect secondhand gift idea. Whether it’s a band tee, a classic movie poster some old-school vibes, or a retro brand logo, there’s definitely something for everyone. 

Plus, vintage tees have a soft, well-worn feel that’s hard to replicate with new shirts.  


11. Second hand vases

best sustainable presents

Looking for a thrifted gift that’s both eco-conscious and beautifully decorative?

Secondhand vases are your go-to choice! Gifting someone a vintage vase that they can fill with handpicked flowers, leaves, or even Christmas tree sticks is something unique and oh-so-aesthetic. 

You can add fresh blooms, seasonal foliage, or even just decorative branches. Either way, they are the best second hand gift ideas for decor lovers.


12. Thrifted board games

best second hand gifts for thrifters

Ready to bring the family together for some good old-fashioned fun? 

Whether it’s the thrill of bankrupting opponents in Monopoly, the delicate precision of Operation, or the hilarious contortions of Twister, these games guarantee hours of amusement. 

Board games are fantastic thrifted gift ideas for family game nights, parties, or cozy evenings in. 

They encourage social interaction, strategic thinking, and, most importantly, loads of laughter. Plus, they reduce waste and offer the chance to rediscover forgotten gems.


13. Secondhand baskets filled with seasonal produce

best thrifted gift ideas

Next up is one of our favorite thrift store white elephant gift ideas – baskets! 

How about giving someone a beautifully crafted secondhand basket brimming with fresh, seasonal produce? 

They can be used for picnics, storage, or even as home decor. A gift that’s sure to leave a lasting impression!


14. A vintage leather tote

second hand gifts for holidays

For those fashion-savvy folks who appreciate both style and sustainability, a vintage leather tote is a gift that marries the best of both worlds. 

It’s a fantastic way to embrace the “reduce, reuse, recycle” mantra and enjoy the quality and beauty of a well-crafted bag that will certainly stand out from mass-produced, new items. 

Just make sure your friend doesn’t have an issue with non-vegan items.


15. Vintage vinyl to remember something special

clever and unique thrifted gift ideas

Next up is a crowed-favorite thrift store gift idea for music lovers. 

When you want to gift someone a tangible piece of the past and create a soundtrack for special memories, vintage vinyl records are the perfect choice. 

If you have the budget, complete this auditory time capsule with a vintage record player. You can find plenty of options on sites like eBay, Fb marketplace, and Etsy!


16. Mixtapes

clever and unique thrifted gift ideas

If you’re a fan of the unexpected and the joy of musical time travel, then gifting someone an old mixtape is the best way to go! 

We absolutely love them because they are something like musical snapshots of a specific time and place. 

The surprise factor of not knowing what tracks are on the tape adds to the fun. Plus, they’re also a fun way to discover new (old) music.


17. Crochet blankets

thrifted gift ideas

If you’re looking for super cozy second hand gifts for Christmas or any other holiday, why not opt for a crochet blanket? 

They can add a touch of handmade charm to any space, whether it’s draped over a couch, spread across a bed, or used as a comforting BBF on a chilly evening. 

And who knows? These beauties might have been made by someone’s grandmother or found in a vintage shop. Hand wash, roll in a towel, and lay flat to dry and you have an epic unique, and cozy blanket right here!


18. Vintage bow and arrow 

epic thrifted gift ideas

On the hunt for unique thrifted gift ideas? How about a vintage bow and arrows? 

A beautifully crafted wooden bow and a set of hand-fletched arrows are unexpected, one-of-a-kind, and adventurous gifts that will look absolutely amazing when displayed on the wall or in a case. 

My friend received this from her husband and she loves it! The old-school ones are so cool.


19. Plants!

best second hand gift ideas

When you’re looking for the perfect second hand gift idea that literally brings a breath of fresh air and a touch of nature into someone’s life, consider gifting a plant. 

Facebook marketplace always has people selling plants. 

So why not give them a new home with a loved one?


20. Ski equipment

best vintage holiday gift ideas

Whether it’s skis, poles, boots, or snowboards, having your own gear is the key to enjoying those snow-covered slopes. 

Plus, gently used ski equipment often looks and performs like new but comes with a more affordable price tag. 

Your winter sports-obsessed friend will surely appreciate it.


21. Vintage tea set

best second hand gifts for thrifters

For those who appreciate the finer things in life and the warmth of a hot cup of tea on a rainy day, vintage tea sets are a fantastic idea. 

Older tea sets were almost always handcrafted with great attention to detail and quality materials, which means that these durable and well-made pieces will certainly stand the test of time. 

You might even find pieces that feature patterns, colors, or shapes that are no longer in production!


Download Your FREE Ebook for Over 101 SecondHand Gift Ideas!

secondhand gifts for christmas

This post was about the best second hand gift ideas & thrifted gifts.

There you have it–the best thrift store white elephant gift ideas, family gift ideas, super thoughtful gift ideas, and so much more! 

From vintage treasures to eco-friendly choices, the secondhand gift ideas above not only reduce waste but also share stories, charm, and unique finds. 

This holiday season, or any time you’re looking for that perfect present, consider timeless thrifted gift ideas to help conserve resources such as raw materials, water, and energy. 

Textiles, electronics, and furniture are among the items that can find new homes through secondhand markets. 

If you enjoyed this article on the best secondhand gifts for the holidays, check out these other articles below!

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

  1. Nataliia says:

    What a great ideas for gifts especially before holidays 😍

    • Denice Anderson says:

      Thank you for the kind words. We think this is a pretty great list, something for everyone!

  2. Heather says:

    I love all these ideas. I love shopping at thrift stores but usually go in with something specific in mind. If I don’t, I get super overwhelmed and shut down. These ideas help to give me an idea of what to look for. Great list!

    • Denice Anderson says:

      Oh, goodness, you are speaking to me! I has some time to kill this afternoon and ended up at a thrift shop. While we went into a book for my husband (and he found three!), I had to reference my “thrift list” to keep me focused. I had three things that I had been looking for and ended up finding something o work for one of them! There is also such a thrill in the hunt!

  3. Rochelle says:

    These are very cool ideas! Sometimes it’s the simple things that means the most and you don’t always have to spend a lot of money to be grand. Thanks for sharing!

  4. […] trends benefit eco-conscious consumers. Gift givers can capitalize on the trends by purchasing presents at thrift stores. You may provide your friends and family members with […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.